Email List Google Plus
 

Football FridayVolunteer for Feast of GivingPhoto GalleriesOn-Time TrafficGolf CardReal EstatePump Patrol
WKEF-TV ABC 22 News :: News - Top Stories - Australian Couple Defend Decision to Leave Down's Baby with Thai Surrogate
Thursday, August 7 2014, 12:15 PM EDT
Australian Couple Defend Decision to Leave Down's Baby with Thai Surrogate
THAILAND -- What was supposed to be a straightforward cash deal to carry a child for desperate parents has turned into an international spat over who said what, and exposed the darker side of a business credited with creating happiness for many couples.

At the center of the debate is Gammy, a seven-month-old Down Syndrome baby with a congenital heart condition who is currently receiving treatment for a lung infection at a private hospital in Thailand.

For days, Gammy's surrogate mother, 21-year-old Thai food stall worker Pattharamon Chanbua, has been telling local and foreign press that the couple abandoned their son, taking home his healthy sister.

After initially denying they knew about baby Gammy, a friend of the couple issued a statement to a local Australian newspaper saying the pair only left Gammy because they were told he was likely to die.

"Gammy was very sick when he was born and the biological parents were told he would not survive and he had a day, at best, to live and to say goodbye," the unnamed friend told the Bunbury Mail, in Western Australia, where the couple live.

Fear and lies

The friend said the surrogate mother gave birth at a different hospital to the one agreed upon, which made the surrogacy agreement void. The couple was scared, she said, that Pattharamon would change her mind about the second child, and they'd have to leave Thailand with no children at all.

According to the report, the friend noted that the backdrop to the surrogacy row was a military coup in the country and "it was very difficult to get around."

The takeover took place in the early hours of May 22, 2014 when Commander of the Royal Thai Army General Prayuth Chan-chua announced in a national broadcast he was now in charge.

"This has been absolutely devastating for them, they are on the edge," the friend added, referring to the days of media scrutiny and debate over their decision, months after they returned home.

Pattharamon claimed the couple asked her to terminate the Down Syndrome child when she was seven months pregnant.

Not true, the couple's friend said.

After the babies' birth, Pattharamon claimed they bought nappies and milk for the baby girl, but "didn't even look at the boy."

Also a lie, the friend added.

Whatever the details of who said what, the case has attracted attention to a largely unregulated industry subject to a confusing tangle of laws and loopholes.

Surrogate 'is legal parent'

In the state of Western Australia, where the couple is from, it's legal to seek surrogacy abroad.

There are no checks for criminal history, and no counseling is required for couples seeking offshore surrogacy, said Jenni Millbank, an expert in Australian surrogacy law from Macquarie University in Sydney.

"If surrogacy were taken onshore there would be counseling protocols prior to conception, as well as a welfare report after birth required before legal parentage is transferred; but these are not steps that occur with offshore surrogacy," said Millbank.

She said the surrogate mother is the legal parent regardless of whose egg was used. The rights of the genetic father are also "uncertain" as "different judges have taken varied approaches," she said.

Australian authorities are looking into the case, as are Thai authorities, who had already announced a crackdown on the industry amid claims rules were being flouted.

Pattharamon said she agreed to be paid 300,000 baht ($9,300) for carrying the couple's babies, money she needed to help care for her own two children, aged six and three. After she voiced concerns about how she was going to pay for Gammy's care, funds started flowing to an online campaign, which to date has raised more than $237,000 (US$220,000).

Could baby girl be returned?

Pattharamon said she's prepared to take the baby girl back if the Australian couple is are "not ready" to take care of her.

She said she doesn't intend to pursue legal action against the parents, though Millbank says she could apply to the Family Court of Australia to have the child returned.

"The Family Court of Australia has jurisdiction over anyone who has an interest in the care, welfare and a development of a child so (the intending parents) could still make their case and argue for the baby to live with them," Millbank said.

"The court would examine the competitive proposals of the parties, probably appoint an independent children's lawyer and do a welfare assessment of the child's needs and then make a decision."

The Australian courts have only ever heard one case involving a child born via surrogacy, Millbank said.

It involved a child called "Evelyn" whose birth was the result of an agreement between friends that went wrong.

"That was in the 1980s and they ended up removing the child from the family that had been raising her and taking her to the other family," Millbank said.

"It was an altruistic arrangement where the birth mother changed her mind about seven months later. And she ultimately won. She got the child back."

Source: CNNAustralian Couple Defend Decision to Leave Down's Baby with Thai Surrogate

Washington Times
Advertise with us!

Related Stories

  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Morning Pledge

    Morning Pledge

    Your kids recite the morning Pledge of Allegiance.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Lost and Found Pets

    Lost and Found Pets

    Did you find a lost Lab or have a missing Malamute? Check out our list of Lost & Found Pets.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Dog of the Day

    Dog of the Day

    Our four-legged viewers love to see themselves on TV. Submit your pooch for Dog of the Day by emailing Morning Meteorologist Chris Mulcahy at ctmulcahy@abc22now.com.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - City Trippin

    City Trippin

    Come City Trippin' with us!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Road Trippin

    Road Trippin

    Come Road Trippin' with us every Friday morning as we discover the best places to visit that are within one tank of gas away.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Automotive

    Automotive

    Find valuable information about buying your next car, including price quotes and your latest automotive news.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - See It, Shoot It, Send It

    See It, Shoot It, Send It

    Did you catch that incredible sunset? Have a photo for your adorable child or pet? Snap a picture of breaking news? Share it with us!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Find all of the information you need on the local events, concerts, festivals and just about anything else going on in your community!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Meningitis Research

    Meningitis Research

    Learn how your 10-12 year old child can be a part of a Meningitis study, courtesy of the Ohio Pediatric Research Association!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Get in the Loop

    Get in the Loop

    LoopLane is a lifestyle community that focuses on positive healthy living, giving, and entertainment. Click here to learn more!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Community Survey

    Community Survey

    ABC22 & FOX45 conducts a general public survey of the needs, problems and interests of our community on a ongoing basis. Give us your input here!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Text Club

    Text Club

    Save money by getting special offers and coupons only available to our text club members sent directly to your phone!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Real Estate

    Real Estate



  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Bay Creek Resort

    Bay Creek Resort



  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - A Feast of Giving

    A Feast of Giving

    Thanksgiving in Dayton: "A Feast of Giving" a dinner, a celebration, a community event, that can only happen because of volunteers like you. Click here to volunteer!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: Community - Free Bankruptcy Evaluation

    Free Bankruptcy Evaluation

    Last year alone, more than 1 million Americans turned to filing bankruptcy to resolve their debts.Get answers to important questions here.


Top Stories List

Advertise with us!

Newsmax Headlines

Sponsored content

 
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Border Crisis

    Border Crisis

    Get the latest developments on the border control issue!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Chefs Corner

    Chefs Corner

    We often invite local chefs into our studio kitchen to demonstrate their cooking techniques and recipes.  Watch those video segments on this page.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Pay It Forward

    Pay It Forward

    River Valley Credit Union, FOX45, and ABC22 recognize the good deeds of people and organizations who make the Miami Valley a better place.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Health Care Reform

    Health Care Reform

    The Supreme Court ruling to uphold the Affordable Care Act sparked a new battle. Check here daily for the latest developments, locally and across the country.

  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Secrets Of A Thief

    Secrets Of A Thief

    We expose the "Secrets Of A Thief". Sponsored by Shiver Security.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Cool Schools

    Cool Schools

    Our children are the way of the future and it all starts with our schools. Join us as our Hilary Zalla goes inside schools around the Miami Valley to find out what cool things students and teachers are ...
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Town Hall

    Town Hall

    Join in as our expert panel discusses jobs in Ohio
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - No Text Zone

    No Text Zone

    Texting While Driving Kills Thousands of People Each Year. Many More are Seriously Injured. You Can Help Make Our Roads a NO TEXT ZONE.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Washington Times

    Washington Times

    Politics, Breaking News, US and World News.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - On Time Traffic

    On Time Traffic

    Get the latest traffic information and updates here!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - School Closings

    School Closings

    Get the list of all closings and delays for schools and businesses within the area, and sign up for text alerts!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Save Local TV

    Save Local TV

    Find out how you can save local TV right here!

  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Raw News

    Raw News

    Watch raw, unedited and uncensored news stories right here!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Pump Patrol

    Pump Patrol

    Find the lowest gas prices, check out local and national price trends, report low prices and get fuel saving tips!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Political Pulse

    Political Pulse

    Armstrong Williams is a pugnacious, provocative and principled voice for conservatives and Christian values in America's public debates.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - News Links

    News Links

    These links were chosen by the newsroom for their newsworthy content. These sites enhance the news stories that aired on the newscast on the dates cited.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Menard's Around the House

    Menard's Around the House

    Menards Around the House how-to videos give you tips for those much needed home improvements!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - On the Move

    On the Move

    Get the latest news and more on your mobile phone!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Good Morning

    Good Morning

    It's Fun, it's fresh, the way mornings should be!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Top Stories

    Top Stories

    Get up to the minute information from across Ohio in our Top Stories section!
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Your Voice. Your Future.

    Your Voice. Your Future.

    As the country faces challenges from federal budget issues to jobs and national debt, your voice is critical to the future.
  • Dayton Ohio News, Weather, Traffic :: News - Waste Watch

    Waste Watch

    How are your tax dollars being spent? Waste Watch tracks whether local, state and federal governments or any groups are using your money wisely...or wasting it.

more »

Business News

Business and economic reports due out today

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Federal Reserve will release the industrial production numbers for August this morning.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

JOAN RIVERS-DOCTOR LEAVES CLINIC

NEW YORK (AP) -- The head of the surgery facility where Joan Rivers went into cardiac arrest has moved on.

Get This

MARYLAND AGENCY-BEDBUGS

BALTIMORE (AP) -- Some Maryland state workers get to sleep in today -- because of bedbugs.

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: FINDING ONLINE DO-BADDERS

BALTIMORE (AP) -- It's one of the ironies of the Internet: while most users are aware of widespread government surveillance, there are still times when Internet users are able to harass people or issue threats online -- and go undetected.

Tonight on ABC 22

6:00 pm ..... ABC 22 News at Six
6:30 pm ..... ABC World News
7:00 pm ..... Family Feud
7:30 pm ..... Family Feud
8:00 pm ..... Dancing with the Stars (Season Premiere)
10:00 pm ... Castle
11:00 pm ... ABC 22 News at Eleven
11:30 pm ... Jimmy Kimmel Live
12:30 am ... Nightline
Complete Schedule»